The Doughnut Project

The Doughnut Project, Manhattan: Pearl Verdict

If you are looking for a serious doughnut shop in Manhattan that has earned independent critical recognition, The Doughnut Project is worth the trip. Ranked #338 on Opinionated About Dining's Cheap Eats in North America list for 2024 and held a Recommended designation in 2023, it sits in a category where most competitors get ignored by serious food critics entirely. For the explorer who wants to understand what a focused, technically minded doughnut operation looks like, this is the right stop.

Portrait

The Doughnut Project operates in a narrow lane: doughnuts, executed with the kind of deliberate approach that earns OAD recognition rather than just social media traction. Led by Leslie Polizzotto, the shop has built its reputation not on novelty for its own sake but on flavor combinations and frying technique that hold up to repeat visits and critical scrutiny. That is a harder thing to achieve than it sounds in a category where every new shop chases the same Instagram moment.

Spatially, this is a small-format shop, which is standard for the category in Manhattan. Do not arrive expecting a sit-down experience with room to spread out. The format is counter service, and the space is designed for quick throughput. If you want to linger, plan to take your order outside or nearby. The physical setup rewards the visitor who arrives with a clear sense of what they want and treats the experience as a focused tasting stop rather than a destination meal.

What separates The Doughnut Project from the broader Manhattan field is the seriousness of its culinary framing. Doughnuts as a category have a wide quality range, from mass-produced chains to shops that treat flavor development with the same rigor applied to pastry programs at serious restaurants. The Doughnut Project sits toward the disciplined end of that range, which is precisely what OAD's Cheap Eats list tends to surface: places where craft is evident in the product even when the price point stays accessible.

For context beyond New York, the doughnut category has strong regional outposts worth knowing if you are building a broader picture. Dynamo Donut & Coffee in San Francisco operates in a similar register of creative, small-batch production. Pip's Original Doughnuts & Chai in Portland takes a different approach, leaning into mini doughnuts made to order. The Doughnut Project's OAD ranking puts it in credible company nationally, even against those well-regarded peers.

Within Manhattan itself, the closest direct comparison is Donut Pub, a long-running West Village shop that covers the classic end of the spectrum with 24-hour availability. If you want a traditional glazed at 2 AM, Donut Pub is your answer. If you want something that reflects a more considered culinary approach and has drawn the attention of OAD's evaluators, The Doughnut Project is the more interesting choice.

Booking difficulty is easy, which is appropriate for the format. This is not a reservation-required destination. Timing your visit matters more than booking lead time: arrive early in the day if you want the full selection, since sell-outs are common at shops operating at this level of production focus. The OAD Cheap Eats recognition also means a degree of word-of-mouth traffic, so weekend mornings will be busier than weekday afternoons.

Price point is in the accessible range consistent with OAD Cheap Eats categorization. This is not a budget afterthought; the critical recognition indicates a quality-to-price ratio that justifies the visit even if you are not local. For the food-focused traveler building a New York itinerary, it earns a stop alongside the broader dining research covered in our full New York City restaurants guide. You can also pair this with broader city planning across hotels, bars, wineries, and experiences in New York City.

Quick reference: Counter service, easy access, arrive early for full selection, accessible price point consistent with OAD Cheap Eats.

How It Compares