Five and Ten

Five and Ten, Athens GA: Quick Verdict

If you have been to Five and Ten before, the question on a return visit is whether it still holds up against a dining scene in Athens that keeps adding options. The short answer: it does, and it remains one of the more considered dinner choices on South Milledge Avenue for anyone who wants a proper meal rather than a bar snack or a brewery flight. That said, because the venue database carries limited current detail on hours, pricing, and the current menu, some practical specifics below are framed accordingly — check directly before booking.

Portrait

Five and Ten sits at 1073 S Milledge Ave, Athens, GA 30605, a stretch of road that skews residential and quieter than the downtown bar corridor around Clayton Street. For the explorer who wants depth rather than convenience, that address is a feature rather than a drawback: the room draws a crowd that is there to eat and drink deliberately, not to hop between stops. Whether you are arriving for the first time or coming back after a gap, the positioning holds — this is a sit-down dinner destination, not a drop-in spot.

On the wine side, the question worth asking at any Athens restaurant is whether the by-the-glass program justifies ordering a bottle or whether you should stay flexible. Five and Ten has historically maintained a wine list with enough range to reward glass-by-glass exploration rather than locking into a single bottle early in the meal , useful if you are pairing across multiple courses or sharing with someone whose preferences differ from yours. That flexibility puts it ahead of a number of Athens restaurants where the by-the-glass selection is an afterthought bolted onto a beer-forward list. For context, if you want a deeper craft beer focus instead, Athentic Brewing Company and Creature Comforts Downtown Taproom and Brewery serve that need more directly.

Booking is easy by Athens standards , you are unlikely to face the weeks-out lead times that define harder-to-book restaurants in Atlanta or Savannah. That makes Five and Ten a practical call for visitors who are planning a day or two out rather than a month ahead. Walk-ins may work on quieter nights, but for a weekend dinner with any group size above two, a reservation is the sensible move.

For wine and cocktail bars that set a higher technical bar nationally, Bar Leather Apron in Honolulu, Jewel of the South in New Orleans, and Julep in Houston represent the kind of by-the-glass depth and cocktail craft that serious drinks enthusiasts use as a benchmark. Five and Ten is not competing in that tier, but within Athens it earns its place as the more thoughtful drinks-and-dinner option compared to venues where the list is an afterthought.

Explore more of what Athens has to offer through our guides: our full Athens Clarke County restaurants guide, our full Athens Clarke County bars guide, our full Athens Clarke County hotels guide, our full Athens Clarke County wineries guide, and our full Athens Clarke County experiences guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Five and Ten have outdoor seating?

• Outdoor seating details are not confirmed in our current data. Call ahead or check their website before making outdoor dining a deciding factor in your visit.

Does Five and Ten have happy hour deals?

• Happy hour specifics are not available in our current data. Athens has a competitive bar scene and many venues on the downtown corridor run structured happy hours , if price is the priority, confirm directly with Five and Ten before visiting.

Do I need a reservation at Five and Ten?

• Booking difficulty is rated easy. You are not looking at weeks-out waits, but for weekend dinners or groups of three or more, a reservation is worth making. Walk-ins are more viable midweek.

Is the food good at Five and Ten?

• The venue has enough of a local reputation to draw a deliberate dining crowd rather than walk-in traffic, which is a reasonable signal of quality in a college town with plenty of lower-commitment options. No current awards data is confirmed in our database, so check recent local reviews for the most current read on the kitchen.

Is Five and Ten good for a date?

• Yes, for Athens. The South Milledge location is quieter than downtown, which makes conversation easier. The sit-down format and wine list make it a more considered choice than a brewery or music venue for a dinner date. If you want a livelier atmosphere, Ciné pairs a film and a drink in a different register entirely.

Is Five and Ten good for groups?

• Workable for small groups. Booking is easy, so coordinating a reservation for four to six people should not be a problem. For larger groups or a party that wants a shared brewpub energy rather than a restaurant setting, Creature Comforts Downtown Taproom and Brewery handles volume more naturally.

What's the signature drink at Five and Ten?

• No specific signature drink data is confirmed in our database. The wine list is the more notable drinks feature here relative to Athens peers , ask the server what is pouring well by the glass on the night you visit.